Philosodata: Rule Methods

NOTE: These methods are applicable to all leaders. The only limit is how much power they have to take away others’ power. It doesn’t matter if they’re a government, corporation, or club.

“Fear Points”

  • If an organization doesn’t have the power to safely destroy someone’s image publicly, they’ll often create a “points” system to scare people away from more punitive measures.

Image Destruction

  • A public declaration of someone’s misbehavior.
  • Usually the most common rule method, and only impacts someone’s reputation.

Rights Suppression

  • Broadly, taking away inherent human rights such as free speech, the right to assemble, or the right to privacy.
  • Most of these are considered immoral unless they’re a response to someone doing it to someone else (e.g., a rapist going to prison).
  • Often, detainment is within a small community of other people who have also violated others’ rights, and often for a set period of time.

Forced Labor

Taxes and Fines

  • Requiring that people give up their money, frequently by fulfilling specific conditions, and can involve a wide variety of transactions.
  • The easiest way to transfer power without any loss in the transaction, which is necessary to keep that group operating.

Destroying/Taking Property

Incarceration

  • Placing criminals together in a confined or restricted space.
  • Can range from complete detainment to casual monitoring of their behaviors.
  • Without closer supervision, becomes a de facto training center for criminals to learn from each other.
    • Besides solitary confinement (which is a human rights violation) or forced labor, the only workable solution is to vastly separate a criminal from their affiliates and community, and place them in a new community designed to give them morally superior purposes.

Bodily Damage

  • The most dramatic form of punishment, where the authority will try to cause pain to that person, either permanently (e.g., branding) or temporarily (e.g., beating).
  • Most forms of torture connect to something in that person’s mind, while a few of them (e.g., flogging) are meant for public humiliation.

Exile

  • Ejection from the group, sometimes forcibly, and frequently to a specific location if the organization has the power to keep them alive.
  • The purpose of exile over death is either from grace by the leadership or from political purposes.

Death

  • Death is the most severe form of exile, with the person prematurely sent to whatever is after this life, using various means to cease organ function.
  • The method of killing can range from quick and painless (e.g., lethal injection) to as torturous as possible (e.g., drawn and quartered).

Punishing Connections

  • Forbidding contact with a specified individual or group.
  • Any of the above, but to family and friends close to the person.
  • All the above methods are meant as a deterrent to future behavior by others, but civil resistance can motivate the authorities to act proactively.
  • While it may be useful to coerce the person (e.g., debtor’s prison), those other people are often victims of the organization’s evil.